Our Legendary 28-day cruise to Canadian islands, Iceland, and Greenland was truly special. It happened to coincide with the World Cup, so we got to see Scottish fans in Boston, and were able to watch games daily on a dedicated World Cup TV channel.
Highlights: The elegant Volendam itself. This R-class ship is smaller than most (1400), and I think it is the prettiest of the HAL ships I've been on (Oosterdam, Zuiderdam, Zaandam, Noordam, Konigsdam, Nieuw Statendam, Rotterdam). The decor seems to reflect Dutch voyages more than other ships do. The layout of each level makes sense and the ship is easy to get from one part to another. The older ships seem to have more cabin space than on the larger, newer ships, too.
Visual Highlight: Captain Rens van Eerten took us right up to the glacier in Prince Christian Sound, with plenty of time for pictures. We saw many ice floes, some with seals sunning themselves.
Entertainment: the three of us love classical music, and the Vivace Trio (Katerina, Irina, and Anina from Ukraine) were superb. They knew their audience, so played short classical pieces and some popular hits. The Explorers' Lounge was packed for all three of their almost daily 45-minute concerts. I would have loved some complete classical pieces, such as the trio on our Norway cruise played last year, but the concerts were a respite from noise and stress.
My cousins went to an excellent pianist and a violinist, a comedian and the Breton Thunder (this was enjoyed by most of the audience, but for us it did not measure up to the group we heard in Sydney on a HAL excursion).
The Ocean Bar had entertainment after 4 pm daily, so I felt it was too loud to sit and talk there. Having one acoustic guitar or piano is a good idea, but the room is so small, the amplification is unnecessary. The Dam Band later was as loud or louder, but many people loved it after dinner. I was usually in the Mix bar watching soccer with new friends, but I missed talking to Ferry, a favorite waiter in the Ocean Bar.
Cabins: I had a starboard side balcony room on the 6th level, which had the added advantage of easy access to a balcony on the front of the ship for special days like Prince Christian Sound and the glacier. Noise from the World Stage and the Dam Band kept me from going to bed before 11, since I was right above them. It was better than being awakened early by moving chairs and tables in the Lido, which happened on previous cruises. I always have an eyeshade and earplugs to use if necessary.
The verandah was lovely and quiet--I often sat out in my fleece jacket and cabin blanket on sea days.
My cousins' room was on the Promenade level, so they could easily do mile walks daily (mostly in cold weather jackets and hats). They liked their room, as people could not see in as they walked by. The only drawback was the bed in front of the window being awkward placement. Another review suggests splitting up the beds, so you have nightstands in front of the window.
Meals: Breakfast at the Lido was easier than usual, with seating almost always available (not the case on some of the larger HAL ships in my experience). Ryan at the Benedict stand learned my order and knew what I wanted as soon as I arrived daily. The omelete line is long, and one poached egg is plenty for me for breakfast. One day I was even early enough to get one of the almond croissants, but the excellent small chocolate ones were usually also available.
Since I walk with a cane, a staff member nearly always helped me carry my plate and find a table. One wonderful aspect of a long cruise (28 days!!) is getting to know the staff and them getting to know you.
Lunch: Usually the good salad bar in the Lido, to help balance out the pastries and desserts at other meals. Sometimes they had the good brown bread, but usally the cheeses were kind of basic rather than the wonderful Dutch ones on the European cruises. I am becoming more lactose intolerant, so had no ice cream. And the pineapple sorbet was not my favorite (at all). Sea Day lunches in the MDR were quite good, and a great chance for me to meet new people.
Dinner: In the MDR, usually about 7:30 after the third classical concert. We have learned to ask for small portions of the main entree, as their size has increased quite a bit since I started cruising in 2013. We found dinners generally enjoyable, with varied choices and good quality. Nearly all desserts had milk/lactose, so I had to be careful what I chose. Service in the dining room is not rushed, and sometimes you have to remind them you want coffee with dessert. Staffing seems somewhat cut back since my early cruises. I do like it that there are many tables for 2 or 4, which probably take more time to serve. When I travel alone, sometimes I am just not in the mood to meet seven new people.
We went to the Pinnacle Grill twice, and food and service were excellent. I enjoy it more since I found I can get a small filet, not the whole 8 ounces. Canaletto needs more pasta options (for my taste), but the shrimp get rave reviews. The service is excellent, and it is fun to see our favorite Lido servers in their dress-up uniforms for evening service there.
Shore Excursions: In Sydney, the Fiddle Group in the Kitchen Concert was terrific. In St. Johns, we did the whole tour to Signal Hill, the lighthouse, Cape Spear, and Quibi Kivi (a very fun art village, where we needed more time). In Akureyri, the long Godafoss waterfall, turf house, and botanic garden tour did not seem to have enough time for all the stops, but the local guide was excellent. We used the local Hop on bus in Heimaey, and it was wonderful to see everything without so much walking. The bus company needs better signage, but people seemed to find it eventually. The puffin cliffs were a major stop for many people.
In Reykjavik, the marathon messed up everyone's schedules, but we took a taxi to Harpa as the shuttle bus seemed a long way away. The gift shop there is excellent, and the Volcano show downstairs was a lot of fun (and educational). The second day, we had the hop on bus to see the church and other sights.
Iceland has to plan for serious winter weather and volcanoes, so buildings are fairly utilitarian overall. The inland trips have terrific scenery in Iceland, of course. It was fun to get to Greenland and more Nordic-looking towns and architecture. My cousins enjoyed their home visit in Nanortalik, even though the weather caused many people to skip this excursion.
Corner Brook is a pretty town, and the local shuttle gave us a good tour and restaurant recommentations. People tend to queue up for the shuttle to get back to the ship for lunch, of course.
Halifax is a great city--we had a good tour to Peggy's Cove and then took the hop on bus (no a-c, and it was a hot day). That way you can see the fortress and the changing of the guard and local sights such as the Maritime Museum, within walking distance of the ship's dock.
Personal Exploration: My cousins had a list of things to see in each port and always managed to also get to a grocery store (they found Icelandic yarn almost every city there). I can't walk as fast or far with my cane, so saw fewer sights but was quite happy with my trip.
Spa: I had a manicure, as I needed to get my nails cut. I learned long ago to resist the endless upselling at the front desk, and got the service I wanted.
Staff: friendly and well-trained. Much better at remembering names than I am! I keep a list of staff so I can recognize them in my survey after the cruise. It gives them kudos in meetings, and sometimes time off.
Overall Impressions: the Ship: older but very well maintained.
Tenders: very well organized. Some wait time, but very well-trained staff to get you on and off carefully.
Tipping: I always take a slew of 5s, 10s, and 20s for end of journey tips as cash goes to the person you intend to have it. I also bought treats for my wonderful stewards, such as croissants from a French bakery in St. Pierre.
Weather: Only two really rainy days out of 28. Some truly spectacular days (Heimaey and the Prince Christian Sound). Two fairly hot days in Halifax, but otherwise temps were 50s and 60s. DO take rain gear and waterproof pants for the waterfalls (jeans take hours to dry).
FOMO: Many people on our cruise had a great tee or sweatshirt that had the voyage's map--apparently Cruise Critic sells them. I really wanted one!
Less Good Over the Years: Since Effy took over all the shops, there are no more tee sales at the Lido deck (I have all kinds of Alaska and South American tees from past cruises), or fun pop-ups selling HAL ceramic vases. I guess it saves me a lot of money, but having so few interesting choices is a lost sales opportunity.